Join Now!      Login

Whole Person Wellness Program
 
healthy.net Wellness Model
Skip Navigation Links
 
 
FREE NEWSLETTER
   
   
   
 
Health Centers
Key Services
 
Walking?
Which of the following in NOT a direct benefit of a regular walking regimen?
Reduce Stress
Improved immune function
Achieving ideal weight.
Improved sugar metabolism

 
 


Send your comments to johnweeks@theintegratorblog.com
for inclusion in a future Your Comments Forum.

 Columnist Bill Benda, MD: Tough Love on Who Owns 'Integrative Medicine' and on Associated 'MD-Bashing' 
 
The following is one in an ongoing series of columns entitled Integrator Blog by . View all columns in series
Summary: Bill Benda, MD, weighs in forcefully on the recent series of Integrator articles, guest columns and commentaries on who owns the term "integrative medicine" and some of the attendant name-calling. It's been a little ugly, seeing the disparate perceptions, hurt feelings and psycho-spiritual-economic rifts between the diverse parties with a stake in the integrative practice movement. Benda focuses on two points he feels must be made, once and for all, regarding "allopathically-centered integrative medicine" and the need to end "MD bashing" by naturopathic doctors and other complementary healthcare practitioners. Benda's addition to this difficult exchange reminded me of what may be the best therapeutic course for those wishing to take this healing seriously: the knowledge, skills and values in the 1994 Pew-Fetzer Task Force work on practitioner-to-practitioner relationships.


Columnist Bill Benda, MD: Tough Love on Who Owns "Integrative Medicine" and on Associated "MD-Bashing"

Summary: Bill Benda, MD, weighs in forcefully on the recent series of Integrator articles, guest columns and commentaries on who owns the term "integrative medicine" and some of the attendant name-calling. It's been a little ugly, seeing the disparate perceptions, hurt feelings and psycho-spiritual-economic rifts between the diverse parties with a stake in the integrative practice movement. Benda focuses on two points he feels must be made, once and for all, regarding "allopathically-centered integrative medicine" and the need to end "MD bashing" by naturopathic doctors and other complementary healthcare practitioners. Benda's addition to this difficult exchange reminded me of what may be the best therapeutic course for those wishing to take this healing seriously: the knowledge, skills and values in the 1994 Pew-Fetzer Task Force work on practitioner-to-practitioner relationships.
Send your comments to johnweeks@theintegratorblog.com
for inclusion in a future Your Comments Forum.


Image
Bill Benda, MD - board member for both AANP and AHMA
The recent series of Integrator articles and guest commentary on who owns "integrative medicine" have strongly evidenced the disparate perceptions, hurt feelings, and psycho-spiritual-economic rifts between the diverse parties with a stake in the integrative practice movement. (See column by Peter Glidden, ND, commentary by Tom Ballard, ND, plus others noted at the bottom of this column.) These columns and articles provoked Bill Benda, MD to try to set a couple of things straight, once and for all.


Benda is in a unique position to weigh in on these issues. Nearly a decade ago, Benda decided to focus his integrative energy on policy - and specifically on bringing integrative medical doctors, holistic nurses, naturopathic physicians, holistic medical doctors and others into collaboration on policy. He was elected to the board of directors of American Association of Naturopathic Physicians and to the board of trustees of the American Holistic Medical Association. An Integrator adviser, Benda is also
associate editor of both the Journal of Alternative and Complementary Medicine and Integrative Medicine: A Clinician's Journal.
_____________________________________

Clarifying a Point and Taking a Stand on Another
in the (Sometimes Acrimonious) Dialogue Over "Integrative Medicine"


- Bill Benda, MD

I’ve been following the thread on “integrative medicine” over the past few issues, and I believe it is time to clarify one particular point, and take a stand with regards to another.

The clarification point is that integrative medicine is, and always will be, allopathically-centered, simply by the fact that it is the unplanned, and often unwanted, child of our aging medical paradigm. It was conceived by allopathic physicians and resides academically within conventional medical colleges. I was a part of its creation at the University of Arizona, and have quite precise memories of the pain and expectations surrounding its birth.
"The clarification point is that
integrative medicine is, and
always will be, allopathically-
centered, simply by the fact
that it is the unplanned, and
often unwanted, child of our
aging medical paradigm."

- Bill Benda, MD

Denunciations began immediately from conventional and unconventional quarters, with one exception – the American public, who wanted then and is asking still for us to stop complaining about each other and get down to the business of providing decent healthcare. No one is objecting that naturopathic medicine is naturopathically-centered, or that Traditional Chinese Medicine is Chinese-centered, or that homeopathic medicine is homeopathy-centered. The time has come to move beyond lamentations and accusations and get on with the business of saving healthcare. King of the Mountain is a child’s game.

My second point is far more fundamental and obligatory to embrace: The time has come to end this perpetual denunciation of integrative medicine’s sire, conventional medicine. Now. Yes, it is an indisputable fact that a significant portion of allopathic care holds the potential, and the reality, of great harm. It is also true that our current healthcare paradigm has fallen under the sway of a capitalistic economy, to its detriment and forthcoming decline. But paradigms fall because universal law states they eventually must, not because they are inherently corrupt or malevolent.

There is no truth to the preposition that allopathic medicine is good only for trauma and a little acute care – or that naturopathic or any other medicine is the only true answer to our healthcare crisis. Those who preach such risk becoming infected with the internal pestilence that has brought conventional medicine to its knees – human arrogance based on the fallacy of entitlement. The fact, the unequivocal fact, is that medical doctors are for the vast part caring, intelligent, best-intentioned people who perform as honestly and effectively to their level of training as any other practitioner, whether in emergency medicine or homeopathic medicine, radiology or Reiki. Allopathic medicine holds exceptional beauty because it holds exceptional risk - in my 30 years I have witnessed great miracles as well as great injury. One really cannot ever separate the two.

"Those who insist upon hanging
on to an anti-MD polemic will
be the ones eventually going away
– there is little use for such energy
in an already precarious world."

- Benda



I find it quite distressing that members of professions that have been marginalized throughout much of their history find the need to marginalize another profession that is doing its clumsy best to take root and grow. No, of course integrative physicians do not, after five to ten years of intense conventional training, possess the knowledge and learned skills of the naturopathic physician, or TCM practitioner, or homeopathic clinician. Such training isn’t fully available yet in our medical schools, nor would one necessarily have the freedom to pursue four more years of study if it were. But to employ such locution as “moron, sophomoric, watered-down,” as well as “bearers of a long rifle and smallpox blanket” does not devalue integrative medicine, but instead diminishes those who choose to cast forth such words of animosity. If naturopathic medicine or ayurvedic medicine or any other philosophy of healing and healthcare wishes to serve the greater good, I suggest they step forward and help guide this new experiment called integrative medicine – teach us how to provide quality care rather then keep telling us we can’t, at least not as well as you. Because in the first place, we integrative physicians are not going to go away. And in the second, by the very virtue of choosing a path not yet accepted by the profession that spawned us, we are the ones most likely and most willing to support and defend you, our unconventional peers.

" (for) naturopathic medicine, an
understanding of and forgiveness
for past sins, real and imagined,
is the only appropriate
response to medical doctors ...
"

- Benda

What will instead come to pass is that those who insist upon hanging on to an anti-MD polemic will be the ones eventually going away – there is little use for such energy in an already precarious world. Naturopathic medicine, as one exemplar, is at the tipping point of its own success, and an understanding of and forgiveness for past sins, real and imagined, is the only appropriate response to medical doctors who are simply trying to find a way to practice a profession deserving of respect while addressing internal wounds inflicted by their education. “They” are not the true enemy, my friends. Just ask Pogo.

So enough rhetoric. The time has come for all boards of directors, and presidents, and executive directors, and members of our professional organizations, as well as medical college presidents, and journal editors, and natural product executives, to put an end to this destructive rankism whenever and wherever it arises. Our students, in their maturity, have already chosen to enter collaborative relationships with each other regardless of title, so the bottom line is that this change is going to happen within a generation, with us or without us.

I suggest we choose "with."
_____________________________________

Comment
: Benda offers a kind of tough-love. Here are the facts. Live with them. There is much that is compelling in what he says. And,
as I have stated earlier in this discussion, the work to find our way through differences, without suppressing them, toward powerful collaboration, requires considerable healing. This takes us beyond opening ourselves to education about other disciplines - an area where we all fall down miserably, still. That's a necessary but not sufficient step. To realize our potential as a powerful part of the change Benda references requires that we venture more deeply, into ourselves as as well as the other, and as individuals as well as professions. I credit Integrator adviser Carla Mariano, RN, EdD, BC-HN, for guiding me in this area.

The 1994 classic from the Pew-Fetzer Task Force, Health Professions Education and Relationship Centered Care, offers us a road-map. Go to the PDF file and open to the chart on page 36. Below are the knowledge, skills and values that that multidisicplinary Pew-Fetzer team identified for creating optimal practitioner to practitioner relationships.
________________________________


Table 3: Areas of Knowledge, Skills and Values
for the Practitioner to Practitioner Relationship


From Health Priofessions Education and Relationship Centered Care
Pew-Fetzer Task Force on Advancing Psychosocial Health Education
1994; page 36


Area
Knowledge Skills
Values
Self-awareness Knowledge
of self
Reflect on self
and needs

Learn continuously
Importance of
self-awareness

Traditions of
knowledge in health
professions
Healing approaches
of various traditions

Healing approaches
across cultures

Historical power
inequities across
professions
Derive meaning
from others' work

Learn from experience
within healing
community
Affirmation and
value of
diversity

Building teams
and communities
Prespectives on
team-building from
the social sciences
Communicate
effectively

Listen openly

Learn cooperatively
Affirmation
of mission

Affirmation
of diversity
Working dynamics
of teams, groups
and organizations
Perspectives on
team dynamics
from the social
sciences
Share responsibility
responsibly

Collaborate
with others

Work cooperatively

Resolve conflicts
Opennes to
others' ideas

Humility

Mutual trust,
empathy, support

Capacity for
grace

________________________________

Breathe deep and look at these recommendations. "Self awareness." "Knowledge of historical power inequities across professions." "Affirmation of diversity." "Humility." "Capacity for grace."

Benda asks the naturopathic profession to move into such transformational depth when he asserts that for a positive future
"an understanding of and forgiveness for past sins, real and imagined, is the only appropriate response to MDs ..." Medical doctors, integrative or not, nurses, chiropractors and other parties must go there as well.

We can wish that such
forgiveness can come through self-will, or via decree that we're over that now. I'd guess that years of directly and routinely incorporating these issues, and through directly including individuals from other disciplines in our academic training programs, in our continuing education, and in professional meetings, until "they" are "us," will be a necessary antidote to the sins, real and imagined, that all parties are feeling. I'd give it more than one generation for its resolution, especially if we don't get going now.

Credit Benda for action on that. He's been bringing the disciplines together in numerous ways over the past 4 years. (See
Political Clout from the AHMA-AANP-AHNA? The Vision of Bill Benda, MD, the Interlocking Director, June 5, 2007.)
________________________________

Related Integrator content:


Send your comments to johnweeks@theintegratorblog.com
for inclusion in a future Your Comments Forum.


      
 Comments Add your comment 

 About The Author
Resumes are useful in employment decisions. I provide this background so that you may understand what informs the work which you may employ in your own. I have been involved as an organizer-writer in the emerging fields......moreJohn Weeks
 
 From Our Friends
 
 
 
Popular & Related Products
 
Popular & Featured Events
Integrative Healthcare Symposium 2015
     February 19-21, 2015
     New York, NY USA
 
Wellness Inventory Certification Training (Level I)
     February 24-May 26, 2015
     Teleclass, CA USA
 
Additional Calendar Links
 
Stevia Products & Info
 
Dimensions of Wellness
Wellness, Feeling, dimension!

Home       Wellness       Health A-Z       Alternative Therapies       Find a Practitioner       Healthy Products       Bookstore       Wellness Inventory
Healthy Kitchen       Healthy Woman       Healthy Man       Healthy Child       Healthy Aging       Wellness Center       Nutrition Center       Fitness Center
Free Newsletter      What Doctor's Don't Tell You      Stevia.com      Discount Lab Tests      First Aid      Global Health Calendar      Privacy Policy     Contact Us
Disclaimer: The information provided on HealthWorld Online is for educational purposes only and IS NOT intended as a substitute for professional medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment. Always seek professional medical advice from your physician or other qualified healthcare provider with any questions you may have regarding a medical condition.
Are you ready to embark on a personal wellness journey with our whole person approach?
Learn More/Subscribe
Are you looking to create or enhance a culture of wellness in your organization?
Learn More
Do you want to become a wellness coach?
Learn More
Free Webinar