Skip Navigation Links



    Learn More     Subscribe    
Join Now!      Login
Breathing Quiz
Which of the following health conditions is not directly benefited by breathing exercises?
hat Doctors Don't Tell You

In Defense of 'Disproved' Homeopathy

© What Doctors Don't Tell You

The following is one in an ongoing series of columns entitled What Doctors Don't Tell You by What Doctors Don't Tell You . View all columns in series
Several months ago, a number of doctors banded together to denounce homeopathy as unproven and a waste of the National Health Service's limited resources. Periodically, the medical profession has offered similar 'proof'. But what does the scientific literature actually say?

On May 23 of this year, 13 semi-eminent British scientists and doctors signed a statement-with all the stylistic authority of a Papal Edict-condemning homeopathy as "unproven or disproved". No doubt about it, they said, homeopathy is useless, and a waste of money, too. They urged the NHS to stop using it-a negative message widely accepted by the media, at least initially.

Was there anything to the attack? The primary claim of the 13 signatories was that homeopathy is "an implausible treatment for which over a dozen systematic reviews have failed to produce convincing evidence of effectiveness". Sounds totally damning, but is it true? Let's take it point by point.

"Implausible". Certainly, homeopathy is at variance with both conventional scientific theory and the dominant medical model of disease and how to treat it. But implausibility is not a criticism. History is littered with examples of once implausible ideas that are now accepted-aeroplanes, meteorites and continental drift, for example. In medicine itself, helicobacter pylori as a cause of ulcers, folic acid as a preventative of neural-tube defects, and acupuncture used for anaesthesia are just three of the ideas that were considered ludicrous and are now considered fact.

"Over a dozen systematic reviews". That's an underestimate. In fact, an in-depth survey in 2001 located 22 "systematic reviews of clinical trials" of homeopathy in the medical literature (BMC Complementary and Alternative Medicine 2001, 1: 4). That survey was carried out five years ago, and there have been two major clinical reviews since then. So, two dozen would be a more accurate figure.

"Failed to produce convincing evidence". This is the nub of the issue. The word "convincing" is key. Note that the 13 signatories are not saying there's no evidence, it's just that that these particular individuals aren't persuaded by it. Well, that's hardly surprising, given that some of them are (or at least were) members of either Quackwatch or COPUS (Committee for the Public Understanding of Science)-organizations dedicated to rooting out the "irrational" in science and medicine.

However, putting their personal prejudices aside, is there any objective merit to their attack? Let's look at the real evidence.

The 2005 Lancet study
Doubtless, uppermost in the minds of the 13 would have been a very recent survey of homeopathy, conducted by Swiss researchers less than a year ago (Lancet, 2005; 366: 726-32). This attracted a lot of publicity at the time, partly because Dr Richard Horton, the Lancet editor who published the report, penned an accompanying editorial, "The End of Homeopathy", which condemned homeopathy outright: "Now doctors need to be bold and honest with their patients about homeopathy's lack of benefit." Although it wasn't made clear in the media reports, the Lancet study wasn't an actual test of homeopathy. The Swiss researchers did no clinical investigations of their own; it was entirely a paper exercise. What they claimed to have done was an objective assessment of 110 clinical trials of homeopathy-the ones they considered passed a minimum quality standard (roughly 60 per cent of the published trials to date).

Add your comment   CONTINUED    1  2  3  4  Next   
About The Author
What Doctors Don’t Tell You is one of the few publications in the world that can justifiably claim to solve people's health problems - and even save lives. Our monthly newsletter gives you the facts you won't read anywhere else about what works, what doesn't work and what may harm you in both orthodox and alternative medicine. We'll also tell you how you can prevent illness.......more
Share   Facebook   Buzz   Delicious   Digg   Twitter  
From Our Sponsor
Featured Events
Wellness Inventory Certification Training
     September 16-December 16, 2014
     Teleclass, CA USA
Additional Calendar Links
Wellness, Transcending, dimension!

Home       Wellness       Health A-Z       Alternative Therapies       Find a Practitioner       Healthy Products       Bookstore       Wellness Inventory
Healthy Kitchen       Healthy Woman       Healthy Man       Healthy Child       Healthy Aging       Wellness Center       Nutrition Center       Fitness Center
Free Newsletter      What Doctor's Don't Tell You      Discount Lab Tests      First Aid      Global Health Calendar      Privacy Policy     Contact Us

Disclaimer: The information provided on HealthWorld Online is for educational purposes only and IS NOT intended as a substitute for professional medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment. Always seek professional medical advice from your physician or other qualified healthcare provider with any questions you may have regarding a medical condition.