Skip Navigation Links



    Learn More     Subscribe    
Join Now!      Login
America's Worst Enemy Quiz
What is the leading cause of death in the United States?
hat Doctors Don't Tell You

Herceptin: more hype than hope

© What Doctors Don't Tell You

The following is one in an ongoing series of columns entitled What Doctors Don't Tell You by What Doctors Don't Tell You . View all columns in series

In other trials, Herceptin improved survival rates after three years, from 91.7 per cent to 94.3 per cent. So the reduction in the death rate is indeed the headline 33 per cent (from 8.3 per cent to 5.7 per cent). But it can also be expressed like this: Herceptin keeps about three people out of every 100 alive after three years-i.e., just 3 per cent.

Of course, that 3 per cent only applies to patients who have HER2 breast cancer. However, we know that only roughly a quarter of all breast cancer cases are HER2-positive. In other words, Herceptin is completely useless for 75 per cent of women with breast cancer.

On a more global analysis, therefore, the drug will help one quarter of 3 per cent of sufferers-i.e., less than one in a hundred women. As broadcaster, writer and breast cancer sufferer, Lisa Jardine, recently observed: "For women like myself, the new drug seems to promise a smallish reduction of an already lowish chance" of the disease recurring.

Earlier this year, Professor Peter Littlejohns, Clinical Director of NICE, analyzed the trial data, and calculated that 18 patients would have to be treated in order to prolong one life. "For every 100 suitable patients prescribed Herceptin," he wrote, "94 will have been exposed to the side effects without any benefit, at a cost of £400,000 per recurrence pre-vented" (Lancet Onc, 2006, 7: 22-3).

But, for other experts, even that puts too favourable gloss on Herceptin. In November 2005, Canadian biostatisticians delivered a bombshell. They too re-analyzed the Herceptin figures, and came to the conclusion they were phony. In a paper entitled "Randomized trials stopped early for benefit", their major criticism was that the original trials were just "interim analyses", and thus likely to show "implausibly large treatment effects". They heavily criticized the decision to stop the trials early, and recommended "clinicians should view the results of such trials with scepticism" (JAMA, 2005: 294: 2203-9).

Even The Lancet, a normally conservative medical journal, has been driven to condemn the whole Herceptin hype. "The best that can be said about Herceptin's efficacy and safety for the treatment of early breast cancer is that the available evidence is insufficient to make reliable judgments. It is profoundly misleading to suggest, even rhetorically, that the published data may be indicative of a cure for breast cancer", said a stinging editorial (Lancet 2005; 366: 1673).

Hype, hoopla and licensing
But surely Herceptin must be good for something, otherwise how would it have been licensed in the first place?

Let's look back at how it got onto the market. The drug was originally developed in the late 1990s for advanced breast cancer, when initial tests were begun with a few hundred patients-organized by the US manufacturers Genentech. It claimed significant "response rates" to Herceptin when the drug was combined with standard chemotherapy.

Two small-scale studies followed, in the first of which nine out of 37 patients with advanced breast cancer experienced "responses", although only for an average of about 8 months (Semin Oncol, 1999; 26S: 89-95). The second study used Herceptin alone, and found that five out of 43 patients "responded", although again the benefit was short-lived-about 5 months (Semin Oncol, 1999; 26S: 78-83).

Despite such modest results, press releases quoted the studies' authors as describing Herceptin as "a significant medical break-through".

Add your comment   CONTINUED      Previous   1  2  3  4  5  Next   
About The Author
What Doctors Don’t Tell You is one of the few publications in the world that can justifiably claim to solve people's health problems - and even save lives. Our monthly newsletter gives you the facts you won't read anywhere else about what works, what doesn't work and what may harm you in both orthodox and alternative medicine. We'll also tell you how you can prevent illness.......more
Share   Facebook   Buzz   Delicious   Digg   Twitter  
From Our Sponsor
Featured Events
Wellness Inventory Certification Training
     September 16-December 16, 2014
     Teleclass, CA USA
Additional Calendar Links
Wellness, Breathing, dimension!

Home       Wellness       Health A-Z       Alternative Therapies       Find a Practitioner       Healthy Products       Bookstore       Wellness Inventory
Healthy Kitchen       Healthy Woman       Healthy Man       Healthy Child       Healthy Aging       Wellness Center       Nutrition Center       Fitness Center
Free Newsletter      What Doctor's Don't Tell You      Discount Lab Tests      First Aid      Global Health Calendar      Privacy Policy     Contact Us

Disclaimer: The information provided on HealthWorld Online is for educational purposes only and IS NOT intended as a substitute for professional medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment. Always seek professional medical advice from your physician or other qualified healthcare provider with any questions you may have regarding a medical condition.